Michigan Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Network logo - an image of the state of Michigan and the UU Chalice

MUUSJN

Michigan Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Network

The Killing of Patrick Lyoya by a Grand Rapids Policeman

April 19th, 2022 by MUUSJN

A TIME TO REFLECT — A TIME TO TAKE ACTION

This weekend demonstrators continued to protest the April 4th fatal shooting of Patrick Loyoya by a Grand Rapids police officer. This is another tragic example of police violence toward a Black man. This email also shares reflections of a UU minister from Grand Rapids and includes options for action.

Rev. Colleen Squires, minister of Grand Rapids All Souls Community Church of Western Michigan, told shared her thoughts about this incident on her church’s Facebook page. They are shared here for your information. Members of this congregation have been publicly demonstrating weekly in solidarity with Black Lives Matter activists for seven years.

My heart is with the family of Mr. Patrick Lyoya. This is a tragic loss of life of a young father of two little girls. I grieve for his parents, his friends, his community and our city. Patrick’s life matters.

This afternoon (April 13th) the graphic video was released showing Mr. Lyoya on the ground and being fatally shot in the back of his head. It is extremely difficult and upsetting to see this young man fully alive at the start of the video and just a few minutes later witness his lifeless body still and silent on the ground.

Keep in mind, this was a traffic stop and Mr. Layoya was unarmed. What prompted the officer to run the plates of this particular car is not clear. We as a community must name the over policing of the Black community and to continue to call out the racial bias that occurs in routine traffic stops.

As Unitarian Universalists we are called to demand justice and full accountability. In the days ahead many protests and rallies are planned. Each one is a call for justice, equity and accountability. People are angry and heartbroken. We fully support free speech, and we must also understand that people have a right to be angry and upset. I pray for the safety of all involved.

Many activists in Grand Rapids have been very vocal about warning city officials of this potential tragedy happening in our city. Beyond justice and accountability, we need sweeping policy and procedure changes moving towards valuing every human life. The events depicted in these videos do not warrant the loss of life.

Again, my deepest sympathies to the Lyoya family. May Patrick’s life continue to matter to all of us, may true and needed change occur. May justice and accountability be swift. May we own the white supremacy culture that exists in our city and may we work to eradicate it from our world.

-Rev. Colleen Squires

TWO THINGS YOU CAN DO

Write a short note to Grand Rapids city officials. Click HERE to write a letter that relays justice demands from the Loyoya family. NOTE: One of those demands has been met: release of video with pictures of the incident.

Also, you can donate through a Go Fund Me program to help with funeral expenses for Patrick Lyoya by clicking HERE.


Hear Senator Stephanie Chang at 10 a.m. April 16th Explain Two Visions of Tax Cuts for People of Michigan

April 12th, 2022 by MUUSJN

Dear Justice Advocates:

The Michigan UU Social Justice Network (MUUSJN) is pleased to invite you to hear Senator Stephanie Chang speak at 10 a.m. Saturday, April 16th on “Michigan Tax Proposals: Who’s Helped? Who’s Hurt?”. This presentation shines a light on a tug or war of values between the Michigan legislature and the Governor’s office. MUUSJN, along with 10 other organizations, is co-sponsoring this event with Gray Panthers of Metro Detroit.

Click HERE for a flyer with more information. To RSVP Click HERE

At the urging of dozens of activist groups, Governor Gretchen Whitmer vetoed a $2.5 billion tax cut proposal by Michigan legislators on March 18th. She invited the legislators to join in formal negotiations.

The GOP’s two bill package is part of an ongoing debate about how to spend roughly $7 billion in federal pandemic relief and unexpected state revenue. The GOP plan would have rolled back personal income tax from 4.25% to 3.9%, would have increased the amount of retirement income that’s tax free and would have created a new $500 tax credit for each child or qualified dependent in a household.

However, critics argue it would primarily benefit the wealthy and at the expense of critical services. While both the GOP and the Governor proposed reducing taxes for older persons and for children, under the GOP plan, the state’s wealthiest residents would receive a nearly $5,000 rebate while lower income families would receive an average $12. The proposal would cut personal corporate income taxes and would force cuts to schools, roads, public safety, health care, housing, environmental protections and would jeopardize federal aid from the American Rescue Plan. State budget officials said the cuts would violate federal rules that forbid using COVID relief funds for tax cuts. So the debate goes on.

Learn more about this debate by hearing Senator Stephanie Chang describe the alternative tax cut visions and what’s at stake for people in Michigan.  Senator Chang, a dynamic progressive legislator, is the Minority Vice Chair of the Senate Finance Committee. She’s in a position to understand the dynamics of this battle. We are proud to say that Senator Chang is also a Unitarian Universalist.


Join MUUSJN at a national UU the Vote Launch this Sunday April 10th at 4PM

April 9th, 2022 by MUUSJN

FLASH ANNOUNCEMENT!

Get ready for UU the Vote 2022! On Sunday, April 10 at 4pm

Join President Susan Frederick-Gray, UU leaders, and partners to learn how you can show up for our UU values and communities in the critical midterm elections. Invite your congregation and social justice teams to join us for an exciting launch of UU the Vote 2022. bit.ly/UUtheVote2022Launch MUUSJN consultant Nomi Joyrich will speak about Michigan Ballot Issues at this national launch.

TIME TO GET INVOLVED WITH BALLOT INITIATIVES

Training is Monday, April 11th, 6 p.m.

REGISTER HERE

Michigan citizens have the opportunity to get involved with ballot initiatives that address major issues that affect people in our state. By getting involved with a one or more ballot campaigns, citizens can stand up for reproductive freedom; strengthen our right to vote; raise the minimum wage; and allow prisoners to return to the community sooner for good behavior. 

MUUSJN is supporting FOUR ballot initiatives. Information in this action alert describes these proposals and tells how you can get involved. 

As a partner with Fems for Democracy (FFD), MUUSJN is looking for more people to collect signatures and to be petition distributors! We especially need petition distributors in central, western and northern Michigan. Being a petition distributor is easy! You will receive bundles of petitions and the names of signature collectors who live near you. Local signature gatherers will get their petitions from you and return them to you. You will then return them to us using a pre-paid mailer.

Click HERE to use sign-up genius to let us know you’re interested in collecting signatures. Sign your name based on where you live. At the end of the sign up form, click the next link to indicate that you are with MUUSJN (there is a drop down menu to record that you’re working with us).

Please join Fems for Democracy for a training on Monday, April 11th at 6pm. This training is for people who are new to working on these petitions, as well as those who have already been collecting and have more questions. We will give an overview of the 4 ballots that we are supporting. Register in advance for this training: https://us02web.zoom.us/meeting/register/tZcrdu2hqDwsE9dhC8sx3lh1N09f7i_HoqDS 

For those of you who are already collecting, here is a list of events across Michigan this weekend: Please sign up HERE if you intend to collect signatures so we can acknowledge your efforts!

Which ballot initiatives are MUUSJN and FFD working on?

  1. Reproductive Freedom For All: This constitutional amendment would repeal the 1931 law that makes abortion a felony and would enshrine reproductive freedom in our state constitution. Reproductive freedom includes the right to obtain contraception, the right to have an abortion, and prohibits prosecution for terminating a pregnancy or helping someone else exercise their reproductive freedom. It also makes forced sterilization illegal.
  2. Promote the Vote: This constitutional amendment would make voting more accessible. Among other things it would create early voting, guarantee the right to vote without a photo ID, make it easier to obtain absentee ballots, establish more drop boxes, and establish that audits can only be done by clerks and elected officials.
  3. Raise the Wage: This would raise the state minimum wage to $15 per hour for all workers.
  4. Michigan United (a.k.a. Good Time): This would repeal the law that requires inmates to serve out their entire minimum sentence. It would establish ‘credits’ to reduce the sentences of those who earn degrees or work in prison and who have good behavior.
For more information, please contact Nomi Joyrich nomijoyrich@gmail.com

Four Ballot Initiatives That Could Transform Michigan! Sign Up for Training on March 14th

March 10th, 2022 by MUUSJN

TIME TO GET INVOLVED WITH BALLOT INITIATIVES

Training is Monday, March 14th, 7-8:30 p.m.

REGISTER HERE

The Michigan Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Network (MUUSJN) is supporting four ballot initiatives and needs your help. For a comprehensive look at all ballot initiatives, click HERE to see the Ballot Tracker article in Bridge Magazine. Four is a lot, but all are important and we’ll make it easier for you to support your efforts with some explanation.

How is it possible to work on on so many ballot initiatives at one time?

MUUSJN is partnering with Fems for Democracy (FFD) a non-profit woman led organization. FFD will be handling the petition logistics. They are a one stop shop for all four ballot initiatives. They will either deliver petitions to you or put you in touch with a local distributor. They will provide you with return mailers for completed petitions. Most important, MUUSJN and FFD will provide training on signature gathering and specifics of the ballot proposals.

If you would like to help distribute petitions, collect signatures or just find a place to sign, go to the FFD Sign Up Genius link. Review the list of ballot communities, and click the place where you live. Then, at the end of this list, click the green “Submit and Sign-Up” button. Enter your name and contact information. Be sure to choose a drop down box menu on the form that indicates which organization invited you. Be sure to indicate that you are WITH MUUSJN.

WHICH BALLOT INITIATIVES ARE MUUSJN AND FFD WORKING ON?

We are supporting and seeking volunteers to help with the following ballot proposals:

  • REPRODUCTIVE FREEDOM FOR ALL: This constitutional amendment would repeal the1931 law that makes abortion a felony and would enshrine reproductive freedom in our state constitution. Reproductive freedom includes the right to obtain contraception, the right to have an abortion, and prohibits prosecution for terminating a pregnancy or helping someone else exercise their reproductive freedom.
  • PROMOTE THE VOTE 2022: This constitutional amendment would make voting more accessible. Among other things, it would allow nine days of early voting, allow voters who don’t have a photo ID to vote by signing an affidavit (current policy), make it easier to obtain absentee ballots, establish more drop boxes, and establish that post election audits can only be done by state and local elected officials.
  • RAISE THE WAGE MI: This would raise the state minimum wage to $15 for all workers over five years, starting at $11/hour in 2023.
  • MICHIGAN UNITED (aka, “Good Time”) This would repeal the law that requires inmates to serve out their entire minimum sentence. It would establish “credits to reduce the sentences of those who earn degrees or work in prison and who have good behavior.

DO I HAVE TO WORK ON ALL 4 PROPOSALS?

No, when you sign up with MUUSJN and FFD, you can work on whatever initiatives you choose.

HOW MANY SIGNATURES SHOULD I GET?

Every signature counts! Some volunteers will collect a few signatures. Others will collect hundred. Whatever you can do will help.

I’M NOT SURE. I STILL HAVE QUESTIONS AND CONCERNS

Please contact Nomi Joyrich: nomijoyrich@gmail.com 248-497-1226. She can help explain the details of the ballot initiatives and the signature collection process. If you want to be involved and you are unable to join Monday’s training, then please email Nomi. She will keep you posted about future trainings.


Urge Six Senators to Reform Filibuster to Protect Voting Rights & Democracy!

January 11th, 2022 by MUUSJN

Call Senator Debbie Stabenow: 202-224-4822

& Senator Gary Peters: 202-224-6221

& Call the Capitol Switchboard: 1-202-224-3121

URGE

Senator Mitt Romney

Senator Lisa Murkowski

Senator Joe Manchin

Senator Kirsten Sinema

To Vote to Reform the Filibuster Rules

So VOTING RIGHTS & DEMOCRACY Can Be Protected

Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer announced that he will introduce a vote this week — by January 17th — to reform the filibuster rules to allow votes on two critical voting reform bills. The Freedom to Vote Act and the John Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act are needed to protect fair elections and American’s right to vote. This right to vote is the foundation of our democracy!

Michigan’s two Senators, Senator Debbie Stabenow and Senator Gary Peters, support voting rights and filibuster reform. Thank them!

Four other Senators need to hear from people in Michigan:

  1. Senator Joe Manchin (W. Virginia) and Senator Kirsten Sinema (Arizona) are two Democrats who support voting rights, but who have resisted supporting filibuster reform. Tell them America’s democracy is being attacked right now in many states by purveyors of the “Big Lie” We need their support without delay!
  2. Senator Lisa Murkowski and Senator Mitt Romney are two Republican Senators who have a reputation for being more independent in their actions. Tell them their support for filibuster reforms and voting reforms are need now more than ever!

Protest the Insurrection & Call for Voting Reform at January 6th Vigil in Michigan

January 5th, 2022 by MUUSJN

Join a Vigil for Democracy Near You To Demand Adoption of Voting Reforms

On January 6, 2021, a faction of politicians turned their backs on American democracy to incite armed right wing militants to storm the Capitol on same day Congress was voting to approve the results of the 2020 election. In spite of former Attorney General William Bar’s declaration that “there was no widespread voter fraud”, shameless conservative officials have been following a playbook of claiming that the 2020 election was “stolen” by fraud. In a recent Michigan ballot proposal, they called for sham “audits” and continue to promote fake voter reforms in the “Secure MI Vote” ballot proposal. This proposal include a ban on using places of worship as donated polling places, likely reducing numbers of polling places. In other parts of the country right wing conservatives are passing laws that reduce the number of polling places, early voting and the number of absentee voting drop boxes. They have even intimidated election officials, particularly in districts where many Black and Brown people live. Voters not politicians should decide elections in our country!

The Michigan Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Network (MUUSJN) joins a large coalition of organizations sending a strong message of NO! to those who would undermine our democracy. This coalition is also demanding the Senate create a carve out for the filibuster rule so that voting reform legislation, including the Freedom to Vote Act and the John Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act, can be adopted in the Senate. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and President Joe Biden have both vowed to move ahead with filibuster reform and strongly support passage of both bills. For a summary of the John Lewis Voting Advancement Rights Act (H.R. 4), click HERE. The Brennen Center for Justice summarizes the Freedom to Vote Act as “protecting our elections from voter suppression, partisan sabotage, gerrymandering, and dark money”.

Join an in-person or virtual Day of Remembrance and Action vigil in Michigan vigil on Thursday January 6th. Click HERE to see a map of where these vigils are and search for a vigil nearest to you. I urge you to wear a mask and not attend a vigil unless you have been fully vaccinated.


So far, the following 8 vigils are being planned in Michigan on January 6th:

  1. Houghton, 5 p.m., 100 Sheldon;
  2. Cheboygan, 7:30 p.m., Virtual;
  3. Manistee, 1 p.m., 70 W. Maple;
  4. Traverse City, 5:30 p.m., (sign up for location)
  5. Battle Creek, 6:30 p.m., (sign up for location)
  6. Rochester Hills, 4:30 p.m.1015 Livernois;
  7. Dearborn, 7 p.m., Virtual
  8. Detroit, 7 p.m., Virtual

Click HERE to sign up for these vigils for more information or find others not yet listed.


Michiganders: Protest the Insurrection and Call for Voting Reform at January 6th Vigil

December 29th, 2021 by MUUSJN

Join a Vigil for Democracy Near You or– Organize One in Your Community –To Demand Adoption of Voting Reforms

On January 6, 2021, a faction of politicians turned their backs on American democracy to incite armed right wing militants to storm the Capitol on same day Congress was voting to approve the results of the 2020 election. In spite of former Attorney General William Bar’s declaration that “there was no widespread voter fraud”, shameless conservative officials have been following a playbook of claiming that the 2020 election was “stolen” by fraud. In a very recent Michigan ballot proposal, they call for sham “audits” and continue to promote fake voter reforms in the “Secure MI Vote” ballot proposal. This proposal include a ban on using places of worship as donated polling places, likely reducing numbers of polling places. In other parts of the country right wing conservatives are passing laws that reduce the number of polling places, early voting and the number of absentee voting drop boxes. They have even intimidated election officials, particularly in districts where many Black and Brown people live. Voters not politicians should decide elections in our country!

The Michigan Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Network (MUUSJN) joins a large coalition of organizations sending a strong message of NO! to those who would undermine our democracy. This coalition is also demanding the Senate create a carve out for the filibuster rule so that voting reform legislation, including the Freedom to Vote Act and the John Lewis Voting Rights Advancement Act, can be adopted in the Senate. Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer and President Joe Biden have both vowed to move ahead with filibuster reform and strongly support passage of both bills. For a summary of the John Lewis Voting Advancement Rights Act (H.R. 4), click HERE. The Brennen Center for Justice summarizes the Freedom to Vote Act as “protecting our elections from voter suppression, partisan sabotage, gerrymandering, and dark money”.

Join an in-person Day of Remembrance and Action vigil in Michigan or join a virtual vigil on Wednesday January 6th. Click HERE to see a map of where these vigils are and search for a vigil nearest to you. The page also has a link for signing up to host a vigil. Those who sign up will be sent a toolkit on how to do this. The movement is offering special sessions for vigil hosts on Sunday January 2nd and Tuesday, January 4th.
So far, the following 8 vigils are being planned in Michigan on January 6th:

  1. Houghton, 5 p.m., 100 Sheldon;
  2. Cheboygan, 7:30 p.m., Virtual;
  3. Manistee, 1 p.m., 70 W. Maple;
  4. Traverse City, 5:30 p.m., (sign up for location)
  5. Battle Creek, 6:30 p.m., (sign up for location)
  6. Rochester Hills, 4:30 p.m.1015 Livernois;
  7. Dearborn, 7 p.m., Virtual
  8. Detroit, 7 p.m., Virtual

Click HEREto sign up for these vigils for more information or find others not yet listed.
Before it’s too late, share this information with people in your community!


WE NEED YOUR SUPPORT TO MAINTAIN OUR STATEWIDE JUSTICE WORK

December 20th, 2021 by MUUSJN

Help Sustain our Statewide Justice Network in 2022

By Renewing Your Membership or Donating Generously

Dear Friends:
It’s been a challenging and a rewarding year for Michigan Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Network (MUUSJN) activists and our allies as we continue to work for justice for all people in Michigan. We continue to fight voter suppression, stand up for women’s and LGBTQ+ rights and demand economic, environmental and racial justice. We’ve worked to support bold legislation to support families suffering during the COVID pandemic.

Click HERE to see our accomplishments during 2021.

Here are some of MUUSJN’s key plans for 2022: ·     

  • Continue working to protect the rights of women and LGBTQ+ people as anti-choice legislators and Supreme Court justices strive to undermine them;  
  • Expand Get Out the Vote (GOTV) work, with focus on encouraging and assisting our fellow citizens who are Black or Brown, LGBTQ+, or incarcerated to get registered to vote;
  • Continue to oppose several types of voter suppression in Michigan;
  • Advocate for affordable water and environmental justice;
  •  Further clarify and advocate for racial equity priorities of Black and Brown communities through MUUSJN’s new Interfaith Racial Equity Task Force; and
  • Advocate for resources for low-income families who are struggling to make ends meet during the ongoing COVID pandemic, such as raising the minimum wage and making childcare affordable.  

We are grateful to generous people like you for supporting our justice movement in 2021.  We request your support to sustain our justice work in 2022.  If you’ve already paid your membership for 2022, please accept our heartfelt thanks. If you haven’t yet done so, please become a member or renew your membership in MUUSJN. 

2022 memberships paid now are tax deductible for 2021.

(Over 40% of MUUSJN 2021 memberships were paid before January 1st)


Can Your Spend 30 Minutes to End Partisan Gerrymandering?

December 14th, 2021 by MUUSJN

LAST CHANCE to HAVE YOUR VOICE HEARD!!!

The Michigan Independent Redistricting Commission (MICRC) is winding down. There is only a small window left to help end partisan gerrymandering. The good news is that the MICRC has been very receptive to public comment and they have worked hard to improve the maps and make them more fair. The bad news is that most of the maps presented have not yet achieved partisan fairness. (More details on this below.) 

Analysis and suggestions are based on research and recommendations from NextVote and Promote the Vote. Analysis also draws on reporting done by Bridge Magazine and the Detroit Free Press as well as many conversations with coalitions including Michigan Voices and the VAAC (Voting Access for All Coalition.) 

The MICRC is planning to vote on the maps on Dec. 30th. If they make any changes to the maps, or introduce any new maps, then they have to open another 45 day period of public comment and this would force them to miss the Dec. 30th deadline. The MICRC is very hesitant to do this. 

We have a two-pronged strategy:

1. Advocate for our favorite map that has been proposed.

2. Tell the MICRC that while we hate to delay the process, the worst outcome will be unfair maps.

We are not striving for maps that are less unfair.

We are demanding maps that are fair. 

There are three ways to communicate with the MICRC:

(Please do as many of these as you can!) 

  1. Testifying in person (12/16/21 in Detroit, 10am-2pm)
  2. Testifying via zoom (12/21/21, 10am-2pm) 
  3. Making written comments on the MICRC portal (portal is open 24/7 and will be open until 12/29)
  4. Send an email to the commission at: redistricting@michigan.gov

The remainder of this email gives clear instructions on how to make written comments and offers suggestions of what to say on each map.

Reminder: the last public hearing will be on December 16th in Detroit. We hope you will testify! More details about testifying (in person or via zoom) are at the very end of the letter. 

If you did not receive the previous email I sent about how to testify in person or via zoom, then let me know and I will resend.

Written comments are made through the MICRC portal. Each map has its own page (linked in this document.) You can make comments and put “pins” or “dots” on specific locations on each map. These dots are color coded as follows: 

Red = Oppose

Yellow=  Sorta like but needs some help

Green= Approve

This method of commenting can be tedious, but its extremely important.

It is our hope that the most egregious maps will become seas of red dots and the most promising will be flooded with green and yellow dots and filled with constructive comments. 

Step by step instructions to add dots: 

  • Click on the link below for the map you want to comment on. This will take you to the map. 
  • In the upper right hand corner, click the blue button that says “Add Comment” 
  • The button will now say “Click on Map”
  • If you are making a general comment, you can click anywhere on the map
  • If you are making a comment about a specific location, you can zoom in to find it, or put the location in the “search address” box on the top left corner. (You can put in a specific address or a city or county name) 
  • When you click on the map, it will bring up a window that gives you the opportunity to push red (dislike), yellow (opinion) or green (approve) . Click on the appropriate button. 
  • Fill in the personal information
  • Scroll down to “additional comments” and write your comment
  • Click blue button that says “Add Comment”
  • After your first comment, you will have to go to your email and “verify your comment.” This only has to be done after the first map. After you verify your comment, you should see it appear on the upper right corner. (If you don’t get the email, then check your spam.) 
  • Go back to this document and click the link for the next map you wish to comment on.

Below are links to each proposed map, (the maps with tree names were developed collaboratively. The maps with last names were introduced by individual commissioners.) There are also sample comments for each map. You can put as many dots and comments on each map as you would like. We know this is a lengthy process. If possible, make at least one-two comments on each map. There are 15 maps and we hope you will comment on all of them, If you don’t have time to do that much, please prioritize the House maps and the maps indicated as being the most fair.  

Feel free to contact Nomi if you want someone to walk you through it at: nomijoyrich@gmail.com  248-497-1226

Make your comments as soon as possible. Be sure to comment by December 29th. 

Please note that most of these are general comments and can be made anywhere on the map. Changes in any county will impact the entire state, so you can comment anywhere on the map regardless of where you live.

MICHIGAN HOUSE

Sadly, NONE of the House maps are fair. Every one of them would likely result in the majority of seats going to the party that receives the minority of votes.

We have two messages: 1. Even though it will delay the process, we don’t want to settle for unfair maps. Maps that are less unfair, are still unfair. Please go back and fix these maps. 2. Of the proposed House maps, Hickory is the best of the worst. If you have to settle for one of these maps, please adopt Hickory

Hickory: YELLOW AND GREEN DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/262/23

Thanks for unpacking Democrats in the Lansing area and/or the Ann Arbor area. All the maps have Republican bias, but this one is the best of the bad. 

Maps that are less unfair, are still unfair. We want maps that are actually fair.

  • It’s unfair but the best of the worst
  • Seat count of 53D to 57R gives the majority of seats to the minority of voters
  • 19 VRA districts with 6 over 50%
  • This is the best of the worst for Communities of Interest.

Szetela: YELLOW AND RED DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/276/23

  • Please Keep Working!  There are no fair house maps to choose from!
  • Each proposed House map gives the majority of seats to the minority of voters!
  • No MI House map addresses the concerns heard from Detroit voters about being able to elect their own candidates
  • Maps that are less unfair, are still unfair. We want maps that are actually fair.

Magnolia: RED DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/263/23

Most unfair

  • Please Keep Working!  There are no fair house maps to choose from!
  • Each proposed House map gives the majority of seats to the minority of voters!
  • No MI House map addresses the concerns heard from Detroit voters about being able to elect their own candidates

Pine: RED DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/259/23

Most unfair. 

  • Please Keep Working!  There are no fair house maps to choose from!
  • Each proposed House map gives the majority of seats to the minority of voters!

No MI House map addresses the concerns heard from Detroit voters about being able to elect their own candidates. 

MICHIGAN SENATE 

Once again, various groups are using different methods of analysis. Some say that Cherry and Linden achieve partisan fairness.

Others conclude that all of the Senate maps have partisan bias.

We have three messages: 1. Of the proposed maps, Cherry and Linden are the most fair. 2. Palm and Lange are unfair. 3. Maps that are less unfair are still unfair. We deserve fair maps. Despite the delay it will cause, please go back and improve the Cherry and Linden maps

Cherry V2: GREEN DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/251/23

This is one of the most fair maps. It still favors one party, but comes closer to partisan fairness. (some people think Linden is the best. Some people think Cherry is the best. Its probably a tossup, but I think Cherry is slightly better with partisan fairness.) 

Maps that are less unfair, are still unfair. We want maps that are actually fair. 

  • 6 Voting Rights Act districts
  • Does well with Communities of Interest

Linden: GREEN DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/260/23

Thank you for drawing maps that unpack Democrats in Washtenaw County and Ingham County. I wish you would reduced the partisan bias further, but this map is the best.

(some groups think Linden is the best and other think Cherry is the best.) Maps that are less unfair, are still unfair. We want maps that are actually fair.

  • 2 competitive districts make this map a possible tie with a small Dem lean
  • 6 Voting Rights Act districts

Szetela: YELLOW DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/268/23

  • 5 Voting Rights Act districts, which are strengthened in Detroit, something many Detroiters asked for
  • Maps that are less unfair, are still unfair. We want maps that are actually fair.

Kellom: RED DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/270/23

This map creates the most majority-minority districts. But it has a terrible partisan fairness score and will virtually guarantee victories by the party which receives the fewest votes. 

Palm: RED DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/261/23

This map packs Democrats in Washtenaw County. While all the maps give an unfair advantage to Republicans, this one is the worst.

This map looks like it was designed to guarantee Republican majorities. Does not come close to being fair. 

Lange: RED DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/274/23

This map creates no Minority-Majority districts and has a terrible partisan fairness score. This map is horrible. It will virtually guarantee majorities by the party that receives the fewest votes.

CONGRESSIONAL

Different groups use different methods of analysis. Some of these groups believe that Szetela, Birch and Chestnut achieve partisan fairness. Other groups believe that only Szetela is fair. Some commissioners have indicated that they will lean towards the collaboratively drawn tree maps rather than consider any maps proposed by individual commissioners.

We have three messages: 1.The Szetela map is the only fair map. 2. The Birch and Chestnut maps are reasonably fair, but not as fair as the Szetela map. 3. The Apple and Lange maps are extremely unfair

Szetela: GREEN DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/275/23

Thank you for combining the best parts of Chestnut and Birch. This is the fairest map.

On both PlanScore and PTV’s Michigan-specific model, it gets close to a 0% Efficiency Gap. This is THE ONLY map that shows true partisan fairness, adequately addressed COI and establishes Voting Rights districts

Birch V2:  GREEN DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/253/23

This is the most fair of the Congressional tree maps, but not as fair as Szetela

Some analysis show this has good partisan fairness, but PTV says this still gives more seats to the party that has the fewest votes. 

  • 2 Voting Rights Act districts
  • Protects the most Communities of Interest in Detroit

Chestnut: GREEN DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/254/23

This map is pretty good, but not as fair as Szetela

Some analysis show this has good partisan fairness, but PTV says this still gives more seats to the party that has the fewest votes. 

  • 2 Voting Rights Act districts
  • Protects the most Communities of Interest in Detroit

Apple V2: RED DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/252/23

This map makes it likely Republicans win most seats even when Democrats get most votes. This map is awful. Not quite as bad as Lange, but still pretty horrible. 

Lange: RED DOTS

https://michigan.mydistricting.com/legdistricting/comments/plan/273/23

This is the worst map. This map makes it likely Republicans win most seats even when Democrats get most votes. To say this map is horrible is an understatement. 

Thank you for working to help end gerrymandering!

Nomi Joyrich

MUUSJN Consultant

nomijoyrich@gmail.com

P.S. the last public hearing will be on Dec. 16th in Detroit, 10am-12pm. This will be the last chance to testify in person or via zoom. Please let me know if you would like help writing your 60 second comment. Here’s some info about the meeting: 

3044 W Grand Blvd, Detroit, MI 48202 

Comment is first come first serve. You can sign up for in-person comment beginning at 9:45am. 

You can sign up to testify via zoom until 9am on Tuesday.  Requests to speak remotely must be submitted via signup form available at https://www.research.net/r/QM252L8


Urge Our Senators to Support Progressive Priorities in Build Back Better Bill

December 9th, 2021 by MUUSJN

Call our Michigan Senators:

Sen. Gary Peters: 1-202-224-6221

Sen. Debbie Stabenow: 1-202-224-4822

Vote Expected this Month
Urge Their Full Support for a Strong Build Back Better Plan


BACKGROUND

The Michigan Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Network (MUUSJN) supports the $2 trillion Build Back Better (BBB) plan that some have described as the most transformative domestic policy agenda since the Great Society. It supports families, creates jobs, protects our environment and makes housing and health care more affordable. This bill was adopted in the U.S. House of Representatives on November 19th. Click HERE for more details of what’s in the House bill from a November 19th article in the Washington Post.

The BBB package now is in the Senate where, in consultation with the Senate parliamentarian, Senators are confirming that all bill provisions can be adopted within “reconciliation” rules that allow passage with 51 votes instead of being blocked by a filibuster. But this requires that all 50 Democrats and V.P. Harris would vote to support this package. Senator Joe Manchin and Senator Krysten Sinema have been persistent critics of the bill. President Biden and Senate Majority Leader Chuck Schumer have a goal of getting this major legislation adopted before Christmas.

Build Back Better Provisions:

  1. Expand Medicaid & Medicare and extend improvements in the Affordable Care Act;
  2. Provides paid family leave to help families with health problems;
  3. Extend Child Tax Credit (it expires this month) and expands Earned Income Tax Credit;
  4. Housing Choice vouchers;
  5. Expand nutrition assistance for children;
  6. Allow Medicare to negotiate drug prices and to provide hearing aids;
  7. Provide universal preschool;
  8. Create good paying jobs that support climate justice.
  9. Require wealthy individuals and corporations to pay their fair share of taxes to help sustain the BBB plan and build a more just society.

CALL OUR SENATORS AND SAY:

  1. Thank our Senators for their support for a transformational Build Back Better plan!
  2. Urge our Senators to work to preserve the strong benefits in the House plan;
  3. Urge them to require wealthy individuals and corporations pay their fair share in taxes;
  4. Support the BBB for our families, create good paying jobs and protect our environment.